Are You Losing B2B Deals to the CFO You Never Pitched?

By Juli Anne Patty, Fractional CMO. Published November 19, 2026.

In brief: A new report revealed that even after a buyer chooses their preferred vendor, the internal approval process involves a number of stakeholders, with finance having the biggest say. Build your sales team a “CFO pack” (a one-page ROI summary, security and compliance answers, two reference customers, and an implementation timeline) and be sure they’re following up to get a chance to present to the CFO if possible.

Key points from the report:

These figures come from VML's Future Buyer Report 2026, a survey of 750 B2B buyers.

  • Seventy-one percent of B2B buyers pick a safe, well-known supplier over a rival they think offers better value.

  • Eighty percent weigh how a purchase affects their own professional standing.

  • The average significant B2B purchase involves 6.8 stakeholders, and finance has the most influence on final approval.

  • Buyers need about five more weeks of internal alignment after choosing a preferred vendor.

  • Price is not the top tiebreaker between vendor choices. Responsiveness (22 percent) is! Then come brand reputation (18 percent) and price (14 percent).

  • Thirty-eight percent of major B2B buying initiatives end with no decision.

What did the new research find?

One of my favorite things to do is to talk to actual buyers about how they made big decisions. If you ask good questions and listen, you often learn that things aren’t as you assumed. You might even gain some counterintuitive insights that help you better shape your message, adjust a faulty process, and close a sale. This is why I was excited to dig into the VML Future Buyer Report 2026, a survey of 750 B2B buyers across eight markets and seven sectors. A few of the key things it revealed:

Buyers play it safe. You might guess that price matters most, but buyers worry more about blowback than cost. As a result, 71 percent say they pick a well-known supplier over a less-known rival, even if that rival promises better value. Eighty percent weigh how a purchase could affect their own professional standing, and 73 percent believe a purchase that underperforms would meaningfully damage their career.

Deals are group decisions. It’s not a surprise to learn that a significant purchase involves an average of 6.8 stakeholders, but here was the real reveal: buyers name finance first as the most influential function in final supplier approval. So if you want to make the sale, you need to be making the case to the CFO.

Picking you isn't the finish line. You might assume you lost the deal to a competitor if the line of communication goes silent, but that might not be true. It might simply be they made no choice at all. The report revealed that the internal alignment process is long—typically about five weeks—and 38 percent of major B2B buying initiatives end with no decision made.

Why does this matter if you're not the biggest brand?

If you're a founder of a growing company, that 71 percent stat stings. It’s not realistic (or strategically sound) to attempt to overcome the incumbent on brand awareness.

But look at why buyers choose the safe option. It isn't that they love the big brand. It's that they're afraid of being the person who championed the wrong vendor. Your real competitor isn't the other company. It's your champion's fear of looking bad in front of the CFO.

So what do you do? Prove your case and prepare your internal advocate to defend you.

Who needs to act on this?

This applies to the more complex or expensive solutions that require change or adoption across a whole department or organization. If your deals take three months or more, or if your solution requires sign-off from a CFO or a procurement team, this is you. If you’ve heard “I’ll take this to the team” from your buyer, it's time to pay attention.

Where do deals actually stall?

According to VML's Future Buyer Report 2026, these are the top causes of B2B buying initiative stall-out:

  • Risk and compliance concerns (39 percent)

  • Budget or ROI uncertainty (34 percent)

  • Shifting corporate strategy (31 percent)

  • Procurement complexity (27 percent)

  • Misalignment within the buying group (26 percent)

Even if you have an internal champion, you can’t expect that person to combat these alone. You have to prepare them. Questions are coming from finance, legal, or IT, and chances are excellent your champion either won’t know the answer or won’t know the best way to answer. If you prepare them in advance for these questions, you get to keep the momentum you worked so hard to build.

What goes in a CFO pack?

Now that we know that finance is more likely than anyone else to be the hard pass (or stamp of approval), the best move you can make is to prepare sales tools tailored to the CFO. A “CFO pack” is a short set of materials your champion can forward to every stakeholder without rewriting a word. It has four parts, and each one answers a stall reason before it comes up.

  1. A one-page ROI summary. Show what the customer spends now, what they'll spend with you, and when they'll break even. Use their numbers, not your averages. This answers budget and ROI uncertainty.

  2. Security and compliance answers. In one document, pull together the questions you get on every security review, plus your certifications and data-handling policies. This answers risk and compliance, the number one reason deals stall.

  3. Two reference customers. Pick companies that look like the buyer in size or industry and are willing to take a call. This answers the career-risk question directly: someone like me did this, and it worked.

  4. An implementation timeline. Show week by week what happens after signing, who does what, and when they'll see results. This shrinks procurement complexity and makes the decision feel smaller.

When should you send it?

Before they ask. The moment a buyer tells you you're the preferred vendor, send the pack to your champion. Tell them it’s ready to forward to their teams and offer to present it yourself.

You've just turned five weeks of internal back-and-forth into one email.

Does speed of follow-up really matter that much?

Yes. Once again, price isn’t everything! When buyers compared offerings they saw as similar, the most common tiebreaker was responsiveness and ease of working together (22 percent). Brand reputation (18 percent) came next, and price (14 percent) pulled in third.

That's the best news in the report for smaller companies. You may not win on brand, and you may not want to win on price. But you can win on customer care. Answer stakeholder questions the same day, and treat every follow-up during those five weeks as part of the sale.

Your 60-second move

Open your last stalled or lost deal and write down the question that slowed it down. (And if you can’t find that in the notes, it’s time to have a think about your CRM management.) Then check your materials: do you have a ready-made answer for it? If you don't, that's the first page of your CFO pack.

Frequently asked questions

What is a CFO pack in B2B sales?

A CFO pack is a short set of materials a buyer's internal champion can forward to finance, IT, and procurement: a one-page ROI summary, security and compliance answers, two reference customers, and an implementation timeline.

Why do B2B buyers choose well-known suppliers?

VML's Future Buyer Report 2026 found that 71 percent of buyers pick a well-known supplier over a rival they think offers better value, and 80 percent weigh how the purchase could affect their professional standing.

How long does internal alignment take after a buyer picks a vendor?

According to VML's Future Buyer Report 2026, buyers typically need about five more weeks of internal alignment after choosing a preferred supplier, and the average purchase involves 6.8 stakeholders.

What is the most common tiebreaker between similar B2B vendors?

Responsiveness and ease of working together (22 percent) was the most common tiebreaker, ahead of brand reputation (18 percent) and price (14 percent).

Sources

Want one tip like this every week? Sign up for The 60-Second CMO Weekly at juliannepatty.com.

Juli Anne Patty, Fractional CMO

Next
Next

Blocking AI Training Is a Business Decision, Not an IT Checkbox